Monday, June 28, 2010

SCOTUS Rules! Second is Fully Incorporated...

...into state law via the 14th Amendment. This is huge, as is the opinion (214 pages). It'll takes us days to digest this, but Chicago's gun ban is toast as of this morning. Here's the statement from the NRA's Wayne LaPierre:
Today marks a great moment in American history. This is a landmark decision. It is a vindication for the great majority of American citizens who have always believed the Second Amendment was an individual right and freedom worth defending.
[...]
Victory is when law abiding men and women can get up, go out, and buy and own a firearm. This is a monumental day. But NRA will not rest until every law-abiding American citizen is able to exercise the individual right to buy and own a firearm for self defense or any other lawful purpose.
Justice Alito wrote the decision on the 5-4 (the Heller majority) vote.

On the way to the airport...more as our experts have a chance to analyze the decision...

15 comments:

DamDoc said...

Hot Damn! good news; however the AP report i read made it sound like it was a "narrow" victory (i guess the 5-4 decision), and indicated that this would only "limit" the ability to regulate guns... (maybe they were not as excited about it thatn we?)... From that description, my fear is that places like Chicago will now play the DC game of just developing irritatingly tedious and expensive hoops and hurtles to mitigate the freedom for exercising this RIGHT. Looks like more court time may be necessary!

John Richardson said...

Thanks should go to Alan Gura, the Second Amendment Foundation, and Illinois State Rifle Association for all that they have done to make this a reality. I'd love to see the 7th Circuit make Chicago pay lawyer's fee to Gura!

Gura is now two and oh before the Supreme Court.

gullyborg said...

This is huge, but it is still just one small step. There will be many, many more legal battles.

Where this opinion comes short is in the articulation of a standard of review for 2A cases. It leaves open the question as to whether courts can use rational basis (would allow most laws to continue), or would require strict scrutiny (would overturn most laws), or an intermediate level (promotes much more case by case analysis, and ensures plenty of work for lawyers down the road).

Anonymous said...

No, Heller explicitly rejected rational basis scrutiny.

However, it did otherwise leave open the question of level of scrutiny, as does McDonald, so intermediate or strict scrutiny are still both on the table.

gunman42782 said...

Outstanding! This is not the end,however, just the start of many years of lawsuits to follow.

gullyborg said...

The Heller decision did not exactly preclude rational basis. It merely offered dicta expressing that rational basis is probably not appropriate while expressly avoiding a ruling on standard of review. A lower court could easily apply rational basis, uphold a draconian law, and send the issue back up through the appeals process.

nj_larry said...

While I celebrate both the Heller and the McDonald decisions, I am saddened by the role that the NRA has played or rather didn't play. In both cases they did not lead. The old saying of "lead, follow or get out of the way" comes to mind. Props to Alan Gura and his firm, and Alan Gottleib of SAF. They are the ones that went on point for our rights. Meanwhile LaPierre and Cox were cutting deals on the Disclose act. I have this feeling that in the next couple of years the NRA is going to see another revolt. A much needed housecleaning. Sad.

seeker_two said...

Disgusting to see how LaPierre is riding on Gura's coattails while making backroom deals to shut down groups like SAF and JPFO....

Throw the bums out....of Congress AND the NRA....

Moosejaw said...

5-4

that is terrifying. could easily become 4-5. Kagan replaces another marxist, so what? only Kagan is young and will be with us for a long time....

Limbaugh remarked about how scary 5-4 was and 'what if it was the
1st that was being ruled on'

Rush....I got news for you.....it is the 2nd that preserves the 1st and dont forget it.

Anonymous said...

As Constitutional Patriots, we need to strike the word "believe" from our vocabulary, or at least reserve it for describing our superstitions, if we have any. The Constitution and Bill of Rights hold "truths the we hold as self-evident". Likewise, economists, the real ones, know that the Laws of Economics are as sound as the Law of gravity and they apply them as appropriate. The same holds for scientists who truly understand and know the possible causes of climate change and our role in it.
Progressives and other liberals can still resort to using "We (I) believe......." As in: "We believe that this "Stimulus (a. k. a.: 'spending') Bill" will create jobs and save the economy." and "We believe that the Second Amendment only refers to the military.", and on and on. They use this tactic over and over to inculcate the citizenry into accepting their rubbish as fact.
We can be so bold, as to assert that we know!
Life Member

Dave S. said...

"that is terrifying. could easily become 4-5."

Elections have consequences, don't they?

I'd like to tattoo that on the foreheads of every purist stay-at-home from the 2008 election. When they sat out they effectively voted for Sotomayor and Kagan and ???

(and that ??? is the really scary part)

DamDoc said...

From the Wall Street Journal Today (Editorial "Five Gun Salute":

"All of this suggests that the liberals have decided to bide their time and wait for a fifth vote so they can overturn both Heller and McDonald. This means that the matter of Second Amendment rights is far from settled, and the National Rifle Association and other advocates had better keep their legal guard up."

Eye-catching Herve Leger dress said...

herve leger dress
bandage dress
herve leger

Dsquared2 clothing
Dsquared sneakers for women
Dsquared2

Moncler Zapatos
Moncler Botas
moncler

moncler
oncler jacket
moncler jackets
moncler kids
moncler branson
moncler jacken
moncler 2010
moncler 2011
moncler online shop

boshi said...

power balance
winter boots
ecco shoes
Bakugan Toys
Movado Bold
Baby Carriers

glenda regan said...

Juicy Couture Clothes
juicy couture Tracksuit
Juicy Couture Sandals
Juicy Couture Earrings
Juicy Couture Flip Flops
Juicy Couture Bracelets
Juicy Couture Purse
Juicy Couture Swimwear
Juicy Couture T-Shirt
Juicy Couture Sunglass
Dsquared Clothes
Dsquared Shoes
Dsquared Belt
Dsquared Cap
Dsquared Hoodies
Dsquared Jeans
Dsquared Suit
Dsquared Sport Pants
Dsquared Shirt
Dsquared Polo
Dsquared T-shirt
Dsquared Swimwear
Tommy Hilfiger Clothes
Tommy Hilfiger T-Shirt
Tommy Hilfiger Polo
Tommy Hilfiger Jeans
Tommy Hilfiger Sweater
Tommy Hilfiger Flip Flops