Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Revisionist History of the AR-15 Pistol

Interesting to see the AR pistol being seriously considered as a self-defense tool as opposed to the "range toy for stupid fanboys" meme that has held sway for years. I recall being flayed alive a few years back when I mentioned that the AR pistol seemed to fill a PDW niche pretty well, especially in the constrained space of a vehicle.


RRA piston pistol

I've used both a Rock River piston pistol (RRPP? Hmmmmmm), which does not have a buffer tube, and a Spike's Tactical 9mm pistol as PDWs when I was on the road. [Aside...I've been using the DoubleStar C3 recently in a Comp-Tac Sports Bag].


Spike's 9mm

I mentioned Gabe Suarez's work on the AR-15 pistol:
We have also found the M4 Pistol to be an excellent vehicle weapon, being extremely light and handy and capable of maneuvering in the close confines of a Tahoe, Jeep, BMW, or similar sized automobile.
Matt at Jerking the Trigger, a daily read, is building up an AR pistol to test it out, and today he clears up a lot of misconceptions on building and owning AR pistols:
I wouldn’t say that I am anti-AR pistol and I also wouldn’t say that I think they are a great idea. I guess that I am somewhat agnostic toward them. However, what always bothered me was casual way that they were written off by many “experts” who sneered that they were toys without ever really backing that up with actual data. So, in an effort to find out what is really up with AR pistols, I am planning on building one and putting it through the wringer.
Definitely read the whole thing, and I look forward to his report. I do plan to build up a .300 Blackout pistol, then put in the paperwork to SBR it. Ideally, I'd like a lower that was already engraved with the Class III info and have the front of the magazine well checkered, which, of course, does NOT describe any of the lowers I've got here at the Secret Hidden Bunker. A little voice inside my head keeps telling me to suck it up and pay extra for the BANE Firearms "Fidelis" lower because...c'mon, you get it! Hey, how many gun companies share your last name, as well as the name of Batman's nemesis???They'll also engrave the Class III markings. Having trouble rationalizing $285, however, for a lower, even one this cool...
BANE Firearms "Fidelis" lower

All this implies that I have enough time to put together an AR lower, which does take about 10 minutes longer than grilling salmon. In the meantime, my recording studio is waiting for me...

...before I go, read this great article on Real World bug-out bags from my good friend Tim Wegner of Blade-Tech fame in American Handgunner:
The problem when traveling via the airlines is you don’t have the luxury of toting a full blown “End of the World, Zombie Slaying” B.O.B along with you. However, there is more a compact alternative I call the BMGB or Bare Minimum Go Bag. This is a small but well stocked emergency kit weighing in at 9 lbs. packed and locked securely in my checked bag after I check in at the ticket counter and go thru TSA to declare my firearm.
Read the whole thing...then go buy some of Tim's "Top of the Food Chain" seasoning!

15 comments:

mahasiswa teladan said...

hi..Im college student, thanks for sharing :)

Anonymous said...

Rock River's magazine ads for their AR-pistol say it's good for 1 MOA. That's the same as touted for their "full-sized" guns. How about a test comparison from someone? (Hint, hint, hint.)

Life Member

That Guy said...

I built up an AR Pistol a while ago, and love it. Very useful as a PDW:
http://rockinaseaofchaos.blogspot.com/2012/11/gun-porn-arp.html

kmitch200 said...

Those things aren't loud are they?

Michael Bane said...

Not loud a bit! In fact, Not a bit louder than my .300 Win Mag with a muzzle brake! LOL!

Now, what did you say? I didn't hear it...

mb

Ursavus Elemensis said...

I've got a Sig PM400 with the included "arm brace" thingie that sort of makes it fit, well, nicely against one's shoulder when shooting. Anyway, it has an 11 1/2 inch barrel and it is quite accurate out to 100+ yards. Very light, maneuverable, handy, and makes a great PDW. I put an Aimpoint PRO on it, and mounted a flashlight. I also am using a LaRue Viking Tactics 2-point sling. Great for home defense, great for the car, (excellent for the car). Can't say enough good things about it. I've heard Michael Bane mention these AR pistols several times over the years on his podcast, and each time he nearly sold me on one of them. Was on the fence about AR pistols for a while, but then I realized how they are basically license-free SBR's and it all came together for me. I'm VERY glad I got the Sig PM400.

Beaumont said...

I've certainly changed my mind about AR pistols. As PDWs, they are probably more effective than full-auto subguns, and I think they might also be better than short-barreled shotguns, for many shooters. I'm planning to build one in '14.

Remington 700 Accessories Overview said...

This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much. Feel free to visit my buy portfolio lighting site.

seo centro said...

I really gain enough knowledge when i read this post thanks for sharing this post with us AR 15 Scope mounts

Anonymous said...

When you read this post you will have the great knowledge.


Visit Here

Gunner Jacky said...


Many gun lovers choose to make their own guns rather than buying them. The most important things is that you should choose the best steel for making it which have strength of 100,000 psi which is suitable to bear up the explosive force.
_______________________
Firearms Safety Training


Grip Pod said...

Excellent! The clarity in your post is just excellent and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work. I'm not usually moved by informational posts, yet your post seriously made me contemplate your points of views. You have provided beneficial and reliable opinions which are reasonable and appealing. I professionally love to write about Truck hoists. Therefore I know the hard work it takes to form an informational post similar to this. Thanks for featuring your wonderful work.The post are absolutely fantastic! Lots of great information and inspiration both of which we all need! Also like to Ions on Android Phone admire the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer! I will bookmark your blog!

Revolver said...

Grateful to check out your website, I seem to be ahead to more excellent content and I believe we all really like to thank for so many excellent content, weblog to discuss with us

Lisa Brown said...

Hey BANE Firearms Fidelis lower is awesome and quite unique. The pistol manufacturers have done a great job. Well I am also searching for a good handgun but will prefer a smaller one.

Jake Roberts said...

Thank you for your interesting and informative blog. I have enjoyed reading it and appreciate the work you have put into it. Here is some relevant information for you to review .
Toy Pistols